
AVIATHÈQUE
all things aviation
Opinion
Profiles
Insights
Analysis
Visual Essays
#jrdforjewar


Zeitgeist
Zeitgeist (German for 'spirit of the times') is the editorial page of AVIATHÈQUE
February & March 2025
After the events of January in the United States, two more major aviation accidents including one fatal, just over ten days apart in February, marked possibly the worst ever start to a year for US commercial aviation. Although, NTSB data shows a general fall in air accidents in the US from 2005 to 2024 despite a significant increase in the overall number of flights over this period.
In recent years, the availability of aviation accident videos (caught on CCTV, surveillance cameras, dashcam et al) and their large scale proliferation across social and other media platforms has pitchforked such events into public consciousness like never before. This therefore, amplifies these occurrences and ends up sensationalizing a public discourse that often fails to contextualize these mishaps against the quantum of flying. This measure in industry terms is denoted as, 'accident rate per million flights', implying the probability of an accident/incident occurring for every million flights flown. And the latest numbers underscore yet again, the fact that air travel continues to be the safest mode of transport by a huge margin.
On the late evening of 20th March, London Heathrow Airport (LHR) had to suspend operations and declare an 'Airport Closure', following a major fire at a nearby electrical substation that supplied electricity to the airport. Shockingly, one of the world's busiest airports' backup systems were unable to provide cover, resulting in the cancellation of over 1000 flights and necessitating the shutdown of the airport the subsequent day causing large scale disruptions to global flight schedules. This in-turn prompted questions regarding the 'resilience' of UK's critical infrastructure that was an 'international embarrassment"!
In the aftermath of the incident, it was revealed that "the airport, despite its global importance, was vulnerable to a single point of failure and the backup systems, including a biomass plant, failed to kick in effectively". The fact that the biomass backup system (burning woodchips), touted as a renewable energy solution, failed to restore power quickly, as opposed to diesel generators, has raised questions about its effectiveness in a crisis and the 'absurd chase of a net-zero quest'. As a post put it quite sardonically, "Net Zero's noble pursuit has left Heathrow vulnerable, a global hub undone not by storms or foes, but by the folly of prizing untested green tech over proven resilience, leaving passengers to rue an award-winning dream turned nightmare."
India hosted its flagship biennial air show and aviation exhibition, the Aero India, in early February at Bangalore (BLR). Touted as 'Asia's largest Air Show', the event has now been a regular fixture for close to thirty-years after its first edition was launched in 1996. The event has also continuously been held in India's Tech/Aerospace capital - Bangalore; more precisely at an Indian Air Force base in the suburbs of Bangalore. The much anticipated highlight for the event this time was the face-off between the US F-35 and the Russian Su-57 fighters! A unique event, considering the current world polity and the near impossible occurrence of such an event (outside of actual combat face-off), anywhere else in the world.
And while the Air Show has grown in scale and scope from its modest beginnings, yet it has clearly started losing its sheen. Starting with the venue, which is increasingly proving inadequate, accompanied by pressures of Bangalore's suburban sprawl, leading vehicular and visitor movements to choke points right outside the venue. Also, with the bulk of the marquee hotels in the heart of the city, foreign/outstation visitors have to plow through nightmarish Bangalore traffic to reach the venue spending a good few hours in the process. Then the whole aesthetic of the event is increasingly looking jaded and a laggard when compared to other prominent international shows, such as Farnborough (UK) and the Paris Air Show or even the Singapore Air Show nearer home. And finally in terms of the substance, there isn't much by way of big-ticket commercial deals being announced. In fact, except for the regulation military aerobatics showcase, there hasn't been much to show for commercial aviation - static displays or flying; somewhat incongruous when you consider India as the fastest growing aviation market in the world. It wouldn't be inaccurate to suggest that India's current stature as a leading, big arms importer in the world is what is providing sustenance to this event. In order for it to stay relevant and grow, the event needs to decouple from its Government-run legacy, be handed-over to professional event management organizations and consider relocating to a newer venue (tailored to host such an event).
In the continuing leitmotif of the India aviation growth story, three new airlines are seemingly on the verge of launch in India or at least that's what their websites and news reports would have us believe. These are:
Shankh Air: Shankh is Sanskrit for a conch shell, considered auspicious in Hinduism and the airline bearing this name should have launched in March "starting with two aircrafts out of a total induction of five A320s in 2025". The airline was to have been launched from the brand new, greenfield Jewar International Airport (DXN) serving the National Capital Region of Delhi, which itself is delayed by a few months. The website though has nothing to suggest any impending launch other than a boilerplate statement - "Our vision at Shankh Air is anchored in enhancing accessibility and convenience for travelers across Uttar Pradesh and beyond. With a commitment to competitive pricing and exceptional customer service, we aspire to redefine air travel standards."
Air Kerala: slated for a Q2/2025 launch, Air Kerala is to be a ultra-low-cost carrier operating from its base at Cochin International Airport (COK) using ATR 72-600 equipment, three leased aircrafts to begin with and "ambitious plan to expand to 20 aircraft". The mission statement on the fledgling website reads: "Our mission is to simplify air travel, making it convenient and budget-friendly for everyone - from expatriates to local residents".
alhindair: a venture of a travel group based out of Kerala and billed as a 'regional commuter airline', this startup will also use Cochin International Airport (COK) and a fleet of ATR72-600s to connect regional touchpoints. It was supposed to have been launched at the end of last year as per its website but there is nothing to suggest any action yet! The mission statement for this one reads: "We are dedicated to connecting people, cultures, and destinations, prioritizing safety, efficiency, and hospitality in all our endeavors." Launch Status: UNK
All three airlines claim to have an NOC (No Objection Certificate) from the Ministry of Civil Aviation in India, a preliminary operational approval and precursor to the Air Operators Permit (AOP). But looking at just the websites and their grandiose plans, one gets a queasy feeling about the flying future of these startups! The litany of failures in the Indian commercial aviation firmament is a constant reminder that no amount of market growth can guarantee success, unless purposeful intent, savvy financial management and effective execution are aligned.
Thank you for your continued support of AVIATHÈQUE.
PK
January 2025 The start to the New Year for Aviation was unfortunate carry-over gloom from December 2024, with several incidents reported in January, including a major mid-air collision over Washington DC that claimed 67 lives. Now, so much has been said, written and analyzed about this accident - coming out of eyewitness accounts, ADS-B flight tracking data, ATC recordings and some stunning videos of the actual collision, and in many cases conclusions have already been drawn and guilt, just about fixed! Much of this can be attributed to a sharp uptick in accident analysis videos proliferating on YouTube (mostly), including a vast majority posted by self-styled 'aviation experts'. If conventional trends were anything to go by, then anyone who's ever come close to an aircraft, regardless of their specific expertise and experience, can qualify as an aviation expert and undertake intricate accident analysis! This 'try every trick to get a click' phenomenon, is just plain abominable and more than anything, insults the memory of the victims and their families. But there are also a handful of meaningful content creators on YouTube, who's measured, dignified and dispassionate technical analysis of these accidents, greatly supplements the understanding of the viewers without speculation or prejudice, while serving the cause of aviation. May their tribe increase! Another carry-over from the previous month was news that Boom Supersonics' XB-1 demonstrator broke the 'sound barrier' over the Mojave desert, after achieving a speed of Mach 1.122, during a test flight on January 28th. With commercial flights on the company's 'Overture' supersonic passenger transport currently slated for 2030, and orders from the likes of United and American Airlines already, it promises an exciting future for commercial air travel. For some quirky perspective, the other much followed aircraft programme i.e. the new Air Force One - a highly modified Boeing B747-8 for US Presidential flight, is also likely to fly by 2030 according to current estimates, after the contract was awarded to Boeing in 2018! A significant development earlier this month, was the action of the US Department of Defense adding - COMAC (Commercial Aircraft Corporation of China), the Chinese state-owned airplane manufacturer to a congressionally mandated list of Chinese military companies operating in the U.S. The official statement from the Department of Defense read: "Updating the Section 1260H list of "Chinese military companies" is an important continuing effort in highlighting and countering the People’s Republic of China's (PRC) Military-Civil Fusion strategy. The PRC's Military-Civil Fusion strategy supports the modernization goals of the People's Liberation Army (PLA) by ensuring it can acquire advanced technologies and expertise developed by PRC companies, universities, and research programs that appear to be civilian entities. Section 1260H directs the Department to begin identifying, among other things, Military-Civil Fusion contributors operating directly or indirectly in the United States." At a time when COMAC has been trying to pitch its C919 (150-190 seats) narrow-body twin-jet, as an alternative to the Boeing B737 and the Airbus A320, this development queers the pitch (pun intended!) for China to be able to effectively compete outside its area of influence. It has long been claimed, that parts of the Chinese commercial aircraft development programme have been adapted from stolen intellectual property of Boeing, Airbus and other aerospace research companies and institutions in the West. Previously, China was (in)famous for reverse engineering Russian airplane designs, both commercial and military and exporting them to third-world countries. For now, COMAC has only found some small regional airlines in South East Asia for its C919 export, other than its home market. And even those sales have been part of larger strategic deals that China has entered into in a bid to show some success for this programme outside of China. Conversely though, Boeing and Airbus are also worried that their successful and enormously profitable exports to the second largest aviation market in the world, may dwindle in the coming years as the authoritarian state mandates Chinese carriers to increasingly shift to a homemade product. In India, day one of the New Year brought into effect, the new 'Bharatiya Vayuyan Adhiniyam 2024, a regulatory act of the Indian parliament, "to provide for regulation and control of the design, manufacture, maintenance, possession, use, operation, sale, export and import of aircraft and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto." Essentially a new law for commercial aviation in India, that replaced the colonial era,' Aircraft Act of 1934'. A welcome initiative, the new act, in tune with the realities of the modern commercial aviation era and aligned with contemporary international standards/conventions, seeks to streamline regulatory processes, boost efficiency, and support indigenous manufacturing, aligning with the 'Make in India' and 'Atmanirbhar Bharat' (Self-reliant India) initiatives. And yet another Indian airline brand followed Jet Airways into the sunset, when regulatory authorities ordered the liquidation of Go First Airlines (founded as GoAir in 2005), as part of a long insolvency process. The airline ceased operations on May 3rd, 2023 and entered into voluntary insolvency on May 10th, 2023. An LCC, Go First was always an also-ran in the Indian market and forever remained in the shadows of its peers like IndiGo and SpiceJet. It was claimed, that the airline was nothing but a 'vanity project' of the scion of a prominent Indian business family and the fact that it survived for close to two-decades, was an absolute miracle in itself! Thank you for your continued support of AVIATHÈQUE. PK
December 2024 As I write this note on the last day of 2024, the most abiding image for aviation in 2024 is now reduced to this screengrab from the video of the ill-fated Jeju Air B737-800, flight 7C2216, as it hurtles down the runway on its belly, gear-up. If one zooms in on the cockpit window one can faintly make out (better visible on the actual video zoom), silhouette of the outstretched hand of the co-pilot, perhaps in a sort of reflex reaction of subconscious desperation, to brace against an impending crash. 179 innocent lives snuffed out in a near instant, eventually. And then there was the miraculous escape of 29 passengers on 25th December, from the Azerbaijan Airlines flight J28243, from what appeared on video footage as an unsurvivable crash landing, that did cause 38 fatalities though. Besides, there were other fatal accidents throughout 2024, including those in Japan, Russia, Nepal, Brazil and Lithuania, among the more prominent ones. A reminder that while safety flaws in aviation can often be unforgiving, yet with constant incremental improvements, accident survivability is also improving. Air accidents and fatalities in 2024 notwithstanding, air travel continues to be far safer than any other means of transportation. In solemn memory of those who lost their lives in aviation accidents in 2024 - civilian and military. 2024 in the rearview Global Perhaps the most anticipated commercial aviation development of the year was the launch of the Airbus A321XLR into revenue service. Iberia (IB) was the launch customer and flew its first long-haul revenue flight on the single aisle jet, on 14th November. By all measurable metrics, the A321XLR is a very capable aircraft, but perhaps a little too 'niche', as per some large airlines and lessors. Long haul travel in terms of conventional expectations is usually associated with large twin-aisle widebodies. Can the audience warm up enough, to the concept of a single aisle jet serving a long-haul route? Unless there was a significant cost saving, would the audience be wary of leaving wide-body comfort (and prestige!) for a perceptibly smaller aircraft. The question also is whether Airbus can generate enough demand to keep it relevant in the long term or will it go down the A380 way? But with Boeing too busy mending a broken house and unable to come up with any credible rival at this time, the A321XLR orderbook is bulging. And talking of Boeing, which was also the other big newsmaker in 2024, but for all the wrong reasons. From the infamous door plug blowout incident on an Alaska Airlines (AS) B737 MAX in early January 2024, with a subsequent internal enquiry finding shoddy manufacturing practice to be the culprit. In addition, Boeing has had to contend with a costly strike by its machinists union which brough almost all of Boeing commercial airplane production to a halt. Besides, there have been inordinate delays to the flagship B777X programme with deliveries to customers now shifted to 2026 making airlines nervous and angry. Boeing's other divisions, notably Defence & Space were also similarly bogged down, including the spotlight on the ongoing saga of the stranded astronauts in space, part of Boeing's Starliner space vehicle programme. With losses poised to continue through 2025, Boeing and its new CEO (Kelly Ortberg) have their work cut out. But a potential helping hand (and a big one at that) for Boeing could be the incoming US Administration and its pronounced ‘America First’ policy, that will decidedly help Boeing gain some ground on the back of coercive trade deals, that are likely to be a leitmotif of the new administration! In a potential future return to supersonic commercial transport flying, Boom Technology, which is at the forefront of building a supersonic airliner, flew for the first time, a scaled down, demonstrator version called XB-1 of its in-development ‘Overture’ supersonic airliner. And while this first flight demonstration was subsonic, yet the prototype incorporates technologies that will be validated for eventual use in the Overture. With the demise of Concorde in 2003, in the aftermath of the fatal crash of an Air France aircraft, which sealed the fate of the supersonic airliner as being commercially unviable, was paradoxically the most regressive milestone in commercial aviation history. For a sector which prides itself on being a driver of technological innovation, the move to exit supersonic passenger travel and remain subsonic, was completely out-of-character. Boom Technology therefore holds out hope with the introduction of the Overture by 2029 and importantly, with sustainable commercial potential into the future. There was major churn in the boardroom of the third largest airline in the world (by number of passengers flown) – Southwest. The airline, long a darling of US commercial aviation came under blistering attack from one of its largest investor’s – the Elliott Management (unsurprisingly an activist fund), which invested close to $2 billion in the airline in 2024. Elliott Management, in a communication dated 10th June 2024, addressed to the board of Southwest, demanded – a reconstituted board of directors, a leadership change and a comprehensive business review at the airline. The biggest tirade was directed at the incumbent Southwest CEO, Robert (Bob) Jordan; calling him out ‘for delivering unacceptable financial and operational performance’ besides, ‘demonstrating a surprising level of complacency’. This resulted in seismic action at the airline with Elliott getting a clutch of seats on the board, Executive Chairman Gary C. Kelly retiring early (read: forced out) and IndiGo co-founder, Rakesh Gangwal being elevated to chair the board of directors in November, after just having come on-board in July 2024. And while the CEO somehow doggedly survived by making conciliatory statements, it remains to be seen how this new flight-plan takes Southwest towards ‘delivering on its significant potential’, as Elliott claims – watch this space! India Domestically the action continues unabated and a new record for the ‘highest single day domestic passenger traffic’ across Indian skies was set, with over 500,000 passengers taking to the skies on 17th November. But for perspective, the Indian Railways also set a ‘single-day record’ by carrying almost 30 million passengers on 4th November - for more perspective, that’s more than the total population of Australia of about 27 million! Just shows the potential for air-travel within India and the gap that will need to be bridged! November also saw the identities of two full-service Indian airlines being relegated to history. On November 7th, the highest court of the land ordered liquidation of Jet Airways (9W), bringing an end to a 5-year attempt to revive the airline by a consortium, after it stopped flying in April 2019. Then on 12th November, Vistara (UK), the JV of TATAs and Singapore Airlines in India, ceased operations as it was merged into Air India. Jet’s liquidation caused a bit of an emotional outcry, mostly from former employees who virtually grew with the airline, but perhaps failed to grasp the depth of irrecoverable damage on the airline’s credibility, financial and otherwise including the symbolic disgrace arising out its founder being put behind bars for financial embezzlement. Sometimes, it’s best to bury the past and move ahead rather than be beholden to sentiment, particularly in the unforgiving airline business. As for Vistara, several of the flying public especially, bemoaned the loss of a brand that was setting the standards for customer service at par with global airlines. But then the merger was possibly (and inevitably) the best way forward to preserve the airline if not the brand, as it would have been a long hard struggle for the airline to any sustained profitability, on its own. There was also the fledgling LCC, Akasa Air (QP), in the news for a variety of reasons. It started by the airline throwing down the gauntlet by ordering over 200 of Boeing’s 737MAXs early in 2024, thus signaling its intent to taking the competition head-on. But the airline has since then been in the news for a sustained set of troubles, most notably with its pilots, who are disgruntled with a whole host of issues including operational safety. This casts concerns on the airline’s ability to be able to compete effectively with a dominant IndiGo and a resurgent Air India. In my own personal experience, when I flew the airline for the very first time in early 2024, my overwhelming impression was that of an airline unsure of where it’s going. There were hits and misses in terms of the overall experience with more misses than hits. Although with only about 2.5 years’ worth of operations under its belt, perhaps it needs to be given some latitude. But then competition is never benign! And finally in October 2024, in a seminal change of in-flight connectivity regulations for Indian aviation, regulatory authorities in India permitted ‘Internet services through Wi-Fi in aircraft, within Indian airspace’, under amended Flight and Maritime Connectivity Rules. Air India was first of the block to offer Wi-Fi connectivity on board its domestic narrowbody services, besides foreign carriers are now also allowed to offer on-board connectivity too when overflying Indian airspace, hitherto restricted. A very welcome change to an unreasonable and regressive regulation which signals a growing maturity of the sector under the present government. Thank you for supporting AVIATHÈQUE and may tailwinds power all your endeavours in 2025! PK
November 2024 As AVIATHÈQUE finally goes live, I am way behind the originally planned launch schedule, I had been targeting. Resultantly, some of the articles that I had penned a few months ago, have had to carry a postscript in order to contextualize with evolving developments subsequently. I hope and request to have the reader's indulgence on that score! AVIATHÈQUE also launches at a tumultuous time for commercial aviation and particularly scheduled airlines. The flying landscape is currently besieged by global conflicts resulting in airspace restrictions, GPS spoofing incidents and increasingly narrower and commercially challenging flight corridors. An uncertain world polity and climate-change related freak weather phenomenon that exacerbate operating risk. Besides, some serious trouble on the factory floor of one of the the world's foremost commercial airplane manufacturer - Boeing. This especially, threatens to majorly disrupt the growth and expansion plans of some of the leading global airlines that have huge widebody orders with Boeing, negating in the process, all potential gains of a resurgent travel period. Airbus is also seeing troublesome delays on account of global supply chain disruptions and is unable to produce enough to keep up with their orderbook! And back home in India too, we are faced with unprecedented air-travel demand. From a burgeoning flying population, that promises to unleash the true potential of the most populous country in the world with a growing and hungry middle class, eagerly lining up to take the aerial route. The last decade has particularly seen a tremendous impetus to aviation infrastructure, especially airports and with record aircraft orders from Indian carriers in recent times, it promises to be an exciting, action packed next few years ahead. "Its all happening here", as the irrepressible Australian cricket commentator Bill Lawry would say in his excitable style, when there was far too much action happening on the field! But in all of this demand & growth story emerges 'the paradox'. As Rigas Doganis (former Airline CEO and noted Academic) writes in his seminal work on Airline Economics and Marketing (Flying Off Course), "The airline industry presents a paradox. For the last 50-years it has been characterized by continued and rapid growth in demand for its services. Yet it has remained only marginally profitable. Most industries or businesses faced with continued and high growth of demand for their products or services would be basking in substantial profits. Not so the Airlines. This is the paradox." Here's hoping (against hope currently!) that evolving world events can allow the Airlines to collectively break this paradox and in good measure. With Zeitgeist (lit.: spirit of the times), my monthly editorial note, I hope to capture and summarize the essence of important events as they happen within the Aviation landscape and particularly here at home. PK